If you’re a fan of fantasy but find yourself searching for stories beyond the bestsellers, it’s time to dive into some hidden gems. Each of these books offers a unique spin on classic fantasy themes, with richly imagined worlds and unforgettable characters that linger long after the last page. Here are some underrated fantasy reads from The Inimitable Books that deserve a spot on your TBR:
1. Down The Well by Veronica King
A city built on myths and mysteries holds secrets that could either save or doom its people. When a young historian uncovers the truth about the city’s origins, she’s thrust into a dark underworld—literally. Down The Well is an immersive read where history, folklore, and a touch of darkness collide. Expect twists, eerie encounters, and a story that digs deep into what lies beneath the surface—both in the world and its characters.
Down The Well
Lore Deoradán wants to be happy when she grows up. But navigating her parents' mercurial moods, moving to a new town just two weeks before her high school graduation, and dealing with her beloved grandma's declining health all make that dream seemingly impossible. Will her new job be the first step toward happiness, or will it be yet another disappointment?
When she falls down a well into a magical world with talking animals that haven't seen a human for years, she must clear her name of the mayor's murder. Although, how anyone believes she killed a Herculean-sized alligator is beyond her. Now, her survival is tied to a mouse with a chip on her shoulder. There's also a cat who owns a pub where the animal patrons might be cannibals, a giant snake librarian who probably wants to eat her, and sentient lampposts who are never there when you need them.
Can Lore prove her innocence, help a newfound friend save the town from a dark and dangerous schemer, and find her way home?
More info →2. The Legionnaire by Samantha Traunfeld
Step into a world where ancient empires clash, and the fate of realms lies in the hands of one battle-hardened soldier. The Legionnaire weaves political intrigue, heart-pounding action, and a protagonist grappling with loyalty and honor. This is a story for those who love complex power dynamics and a dash of gritty realism in their fantasy. Think Roman legions with a touch of magic, and you’ll feel right at home.
The Legionnaire
Saiden, a Blood-Cursed legionnaire—blessed by both the God of Life and Goddess of Death—is a paradox. Called both “death-bringer” and “world-ender,” she is surprisingly careful about taking lives and proving herself to be a monster. Torn between her loyalty to her queen and the need to protect her people, Saiden struggles to decide who she is going to be in a world that has already cast her aside.
Queen Loralei is hiding the fact that she’s been blessed by the God of Life while navigating the manipulative and dangerous landscape of ruling a kingdom. When she discovers a mysterious prisoner in her dungeons, she begins to unravel a complicated plot that shadows her reign and would change the course of history.
Mozare, gifted by the Goddess of Death with the powers to control shadows, is hiding lots of secrets in the dark. As Saiden’s legionnaire partner, he would do everything to protect her—even if that means killing the queen she swore to protect to save her from a fate worse than death.
With friends and enemies becoming indistinguishable from each other, can these three individuals survive long enough to fulfill their destinies without losing those closest to them, or will their missions irreparably ruin them—and possibly the entire kingdom?
More info →3. A Diamond Bright and Broken by Holly Davis
In a kingdom where light is power, what happens when darkness becomes your ally? A Diamond Bright and Broken delivers a story filled with enchantment, betrayal, and the delicate balance between hope and despair. This novel explores the shadows that lie behind every shimmer, offering a rich narrative about discovering strength where others see weakness. It’s a must-read for those who appreciate lyrical prose and tales that blend beauty with brokenness.
A Diamond Bright and Broken
Sixteen-year-old Cadence was born with the ability to cry tears of diamonds–a secret talent her parents have abused to climb the royal ranks thanks to the infinite source of wealth. At their command, she cries diamonds to pay for the pricey treatments for her sister’s neuromuscular disorder. Regardless of the pain, she’ll do anything for her sister, who weakens by the day.
When the prince heckles Cadence at the King’s Summer Solstice Ball about her sister’s disability while dancing in the ballroom, she’s left on the verge of tears, threatening to expose her power. She is saved by a mysteriously charming girl who sweeps in to take the next dance—and the single diamond Cadence cried. The stranger reveals the Magi Queen sent her to tell Cadence that she’s a mage, and that her power is a curse.
Yearning to discover the secrets behind her powers, Cadence sets off for the City of Magi. To claim the life she wants, Cadence must embrace her power—before she loses the bright spots in her otherwise sad existence. After all, even diamonds can shatter.
More info →4. The Storm Gathers by Maelan Holladay
When magic meets a brewing rebellion, the storm that follows is more than just a metaphor. The Storm Gathers is a tale of elemental powers, hidden secrets, and a world on the brink of upheaval. With characters as unpredictable as the tempest they face, this book will keep you turning pages well into the night. It’s perfect for readers who enjoy intense world-building and the ever-present tension of what’s lurking in the shadows.
The Storm Gathers
One day, my dear daughter, you will destroy the world.
After being forced from her home five years ago, Alana Zaya has finally been given the opportunity to return and claim her rightful place on the Okaron throne. When her voyage is waylaid by pirates, she soon finds herself stranded at sea, surrounded by strangers harboring dark secrets. But hers are perhaps the darkest of all.
Across the world, Rae Toma is a warrior who can't walk away from a fight. After years of using her skills to rebel against the regime that trained her, her treachery is revealed, forcing her to flee into the Shatter—a maze of islands that no one has ever returned from.
There, she finds Nur Del Sue, a Stormwitch on a mission to prove herself in a world determined to ignore her.
Forced from their homes, can these characters survive long enough to uncover the deadly mysteries at the heart of their world?
More info →5. Heirs of Bone and Sea by Kay Adams
Magic is as old as the tides, and in Heirs of Bone and Sea, it’s just as relentless. Follow a crew of misfits as they navigate treacherous waters, ancient curses, and a legacy that’s more burden than blessing. This is a book that marries adventure with introspection, offering a story as deep as the ocean it sails. For fans of stories where the sea holds secrets and loyalty is tested at every turn, this one’s for you.
Heirs of Bone and Sea
Climb the tower. Kill the princess.
Evhen, princess—no, queen—of Vodaeard, is on a revenge mission. After witnessing her parents' brutal murder by the king of Marama and the horror of his undead army, she's vowed to kill his daughter. It'll be poetic justice and also take away his supernatural edge in the war. But when she realizes the princess might be an ignorant pawn, she changes course and hides her royal identity—after all, she can't trust an enemy, no matter how beautiful she is.
Stay alive. Break the curse.
Princess Kalei of Marama is moon-blessed, allowing her to resurrect her kingdom's loyal subjects. But when she's attacked in her safe lighthouse by a fiery pirate, her worldview is shattered once she learns what her power is really being used for. Determined to prove her innocence and willingness to stop her father, she has no choice but to trust her would-be killer to safely deliver her to the Vodaeardean princess. But who can she trust in when it seems Captain Evhen is not the only one who wants her dead?
More info →Why These Books Deserve Your Attention
What makes these books stand out is their ability to take familiar elements—like magic, ancient cities, and epic quests—and turn them into something refreshingly new. Each of these stories challenges the boundaries of the fantasy genre, delivering unique narratives that pack a punch.
Whether you’re in the mood for heart-stopping adventure, subtle magic, or complex characters with intricate backstories, these underrated reads from The Inimitable Books won’t disappoint. Give them a chance, and you might just find your next favorite world to escape into. Happy reading! 📚✨
What other underrated fantasy books have you discovered lately? Let us know in the comments!